Top Questions to Ask Your Car Accident Lawyer

When you walk into a lawyer’s office after a car accident, you deserve straight answers. The consultation is not just about the law firm asking you questions to see if your case is the right fit for them. It is also your chance to find out if they are the right fit to fight for you.
We understand that when you are looking for a car accident attorney, you are in a lot of pain, stressed, and need help. Knowing the right questions to ask a car accident lawyer at your first consultation puts you in a position of power.
At Rosen Justice Injury Lawyers, we invite you to ask us the tough questions. We want to prove to you that we will be your relentless advocate.
What to Ask a Car Accident Lawyer in Pennsylvania
Here’s a list of car accident lawyer questions to ask at your consultation with a law firm you’re interested in hiring for your case. We’ll explain how to evaluate the answers below.
- What experience do you have with car accident cases in Philadelphia?
- What results have you achieved for clients like me?
- How do you charge fees?
- How will you communicate with me?
- What is your strategy for my case?
- What problems do you see with my case?
- How long will my case take?
- Who will handle my case day to day?
- What compensation can I expect?
These questions cover the basics, but you should feel free to develop your own, based on your specific situation.
1. What Experience Do You Have with Car Accident Cases in Philadelphia?
Experience is the foundation of your case. Not every lawyer who handles personal injury cases has deep experience with car accidents. Ask how many car accident cases they have handled, how often they go up against insurance companies in court, and what kinds of results they have secured for our clients.
At Rosen Justice Injury Lawyers, with over 75 years of combined experience, we know how local courts, judges, and insurers operate. That kind of knowledge shapes every strategy we build.
2. What Results Have You Achieved for Clients Like Me?
Results tell you whether a lawyer can back up their talk. You should ask about past verdicts and settlements in cases that look like yours. If you were hit by a drunk driver, for example, you want to know how they have handled those claims. If you lost income because of your injuries, you want to hear how they have fought for wage loss recovery in the past.
Our attorneys at Rosen Justice Injury Lawyers have recovered millions for car accident victims across Philadelphia and the surrounding counties. We are ready to explain what those results mean for the challenges in your case.
3. How Do You Charge Fees?
Money matters when you are hurt and out of work. Some lawyers hide their fees in fine print. You should never leave a consultation without a clear understanding of how your lawyer gets paid.
At Rosen Justice Injury Lawyers, we work on contingency, which means you never pay us up front. We only get paid if we win money for you. Ask us what percentage we take, what costs might come out of a settlement, and how those expenses are handled along the way.
4. How Will You Communicate with Me?
One of the biggest complaints clients have about lawyers is poor communication. You deserve to know how often you will hear from your legal team, how quickly they return calls, and who you can contact if you have a question. Ask whether you will speak directly with your attorney, how often they give case updates, and if you can expect honest answers even when the news is tough.
5. What Is Your Strategy for My Case?
Every car accident case needs a tailored approach. Ask the law firm how they plan to investigate your crash, whether they expect to settle or take your case to trial, and what steps they will take to pressure the insurance company to pay. Their strategy should usually include gathering police reports, medical records, witness statements, and expert testimony.
6. What Problems Do You See with My Case?
A good lawyer will not just tell you what sounds positive. You need to hear about the obstacles as well. Maybe the insurance company is going to argue that you were partly at fault and are owed nothing based on Pennsylvania’s modified comparative negligence law. Maybe your injuries are serious, but the medical documentation is weak. Maybe the at-fault driver does not have enough insurance coverage. A good law firm will point out those challenges and explain how they plan to deal with them. You deserve an honest assessment of the uphill battles ahead.
7. How Long Will My Case Take?
Car accident cases do not move overnight. Some settle quickly if the facts are clear and the insurance company is reasonable. Others take months or even years, especially if the case goes to trial. Ask the law firm for a timeline so you can set realistic expectations. They should explain how medical treatment, negotiations, and court schedules can all affect the length of your case. They should give you a clear picture so you can plan your life around the process.
8. Who Will Handle My Case Day to Day?
You want to know who is doing the work on your file. Some law firms bring you in with a senior partner but pass you off to junior lawyers you never meet. Ask them who will return your calls, who will attend your hearings, and who will be responsible for strategy decisions. You should know the people fighting for you.
9. What Compensation Can I Expect?
While no lawyer can predict an exact dollar amount, they should walk you through the categories of damages you may recover. These often include medical expenses, lost wages, property damage, and pain and suffering. They should explain how these numbers are calculated and what factors may increase or decrease them. Be clear that they should not inflate expectations just to win you over. Instead, they tell you the realistic value range so you can make informed decisions.
Contact Us for a Free Consultation Today: Bring the List of Questions to Ask a Car Accident Lawyer
The questions you ask in your first meeting with a lawyer can shape the entire outcome of your case. You deserve clear, direct answers about experience, fees, communication, strategy, and results.
At Rosen Justice Injury Lawyers, we are ready to give you those answers and to stand by your side from consultation to resolution. If you were hurt in a car accident in Philadelphia, Delaware, Montgomery, or Bucks County, we invite you to bring these questions to us and see how we measure up. Call or message us today.

